deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
  • Art Print
  • Canvas
  • Photo
more ▶

More from *BenoitPaille

Featured in Groups:

Details

August 21, 2010
12.2 MB
5994×3996
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 125
Favourites: 2,100 [who?]

Views: 36,245 (0 today)
[x]
:iconbenoitpaille:
A stranger: train amsterdam to brussel



Démarche:
Interroger le monde moderne dans lequel on vit et tenter de briser l'individualisme et l’anonymat de la grande ville. En allant dans des Non-lieux (métro, centre commercial, rue passante à l’heure de pointe) et en demandant à des étrangers de les prendre en photo, je brise pour quelques instants le fonctionnement habituel de ce monde moderne. Je rend ces Non-lieux existants en y créant un événement dont l’étranger va se souvenir.

Approach to photography:
Questioning the modern world in which we are living and trying to break this individualism and the anonymity of the big city. By going into “Non-lieux” (no existing places) (subways, malls, and crowded streets at rush hours …;) and by talking to people to take photos, I break the usual way this modern world works for a few instants. I make real these “non-lieux” by creating an event that the stranger will remember.
Add a Comment:
 
:iconperfling:
First of all, superb photo!! Completely brightened my day. :)

Now on to the critique part...

Vision: I like your approach to the process. It's not only to just break normality by taking pictures, but to also engage the subject in conversation, and through that, the picture is given personality.

Originality: I'm afraid to say that this approach and the results from it are widely practiced. I'm not sure what it is about this photo (perhaps it's the personality of the people, the individual elements like the bow-ties, expressions, or hair, or even just the color palette), but it seems to stand out from other photos I've seen. I truly enjoy it.

Technique: What can I say? The framing is perfect; not too much, not too little, just enough to focus on the people. The colors are good. There aren't distractors in the background. You captured the characters of the people artistically. Beautifully done.

Impact: I'm not sure about how other people would react, but this brought a smile to my face; the people are endearing and it's well executed. My only issue would be that your excellent developmental process does not come through. It's a double-edged sword in my opinion; in order to show this is not a posed shoot, you would need to make the situation look more natural, but to do that would add clutter to the picture and would only take away from the picture. I think you handled it in the best way possible.


Overall, I absolutely love it. :heart:
What do you think?
The Artist thought this was FAIR
7 out of 7 deviants thought this was fair.

:iconthatmexicanuzer:
Man, you inspired me with this picture, I want to become a photographer in the future, and this pic just makes me want to learn the genre even more.
What you say is so true, people should just take picture to strangers they see in public places, though you might don't want to over act when you ask, they might call the police.
Anyways back to you, the way the red tie guys sees the other guy is so epic and it looks very authentic, its like when I sat near a gay dude in the bus of school, and I was looking at him just like the red tie dude was doing it, so it is a very good and AWESOME job you've done
What do you think?
The Artist thought this was FAIR
30 out of 34 deviants thought this was fair.

The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork

Please sign up or login to post a critique.

love 9 9 joy 4 4 wow 1 1 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconlndfrance:
~LNDFrance Jan 12, 2013  Hobbyist General Artist
Excellente démarche. C'est délicat de demander à un étranger d'être photographié en plus, chapeau ! C'est fantastique parce que, après avoir parcouru rapidement une partie de cette série, je trouve à chaque cliché une puissance vraiment particulière, comme si un morceau de l'âme de chacun accompagnait sa photo. Vraiment un grand bravo, et félicitations pour la DD :)
Reply
:iconbenoitpaille:
hé bien merci , content que ca te plaise
Reply
:iconzedrados:
Great Shot - Great Gallery
Reply
:iconopima:
Est-tu Marc Augé? :)
Reply
:iconbenoitpaille:
ici c'est la version courte de la démarche dans la longue je le cite bien sur,
Reply
:iconkittylavishh:
~KittyLavishh Mar 29, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
lol this captures the personalities in one blow :) good job
Reply
:icontilly-bungard:
~tilly-bungard Feb 19, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Oh. I like this a lot. I love your whole sequence of strangers. You've been asked alot but I'll ask again: What do you say to these people? Do you decide how they will pose or do they? I would love to know. I tihnk this is the purest form of photography. I love it.
Reply
:icongothicshade:
nice concept for real. You give modern people a chance to experience a meaningful moment in a meaningless world. That's what Art's task has become nowadays I suppose.
Reply
:iconemsyugiri:
~EMSYugiri Aug 26, 2011  Student General Artist
unique!
Reply
:iconsomethingfunny18:
~somethingfunny18 Aug 10, 2011   Photographer
I absolutely love this! it's just brilliant!
Reply
Add a Comment: